![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
HOME |
PRESS RELEASES |
LINKS |
ABOUT US |
CONTACT US |
For Immediate Release. Press Release 22 November 2026
It is highly concerning how the Irish Government has selectively used
Brussels to strip an Irish citizen of constitutional rights it is sworn
to uphold at home, in the placement of Irish journalist Chay Bowes on
the EU sanctions list, when he has broken no Irish law.
The selectivity of this approach is stark; while the Government has
repeatedly shielded the Russian-owned Aughinish Alumina refinery on the
Shannon Estuary from EU sanctions – even after the EU's own sanctions
envoy, Irishman David O'Sullivan, who strangely stepped down the day
after the sanctions list was published, acknowledged
its shipments supply Russia's military-industrial complex – it readily
consented to sanctioning an individual Irish citizen for his work as a
journalist without due process. Similarly, we see EU procedures, such
as Projects of Common Interest and the EU N-1 infrastructure standard,
being used to push for the importation of US fracked gas via LNG
terminals, despite Ireland banning fracking on public-health, climate,
and environmental grounds in 2017.
Environmental challenges in the Irish courts normally seek to
protect EU power from national interference. The application of those
principles should go both ways and it is clear that EU procedures were
used here to hollow out domestic constitutional rights and protections
– especially as the Government was not obliged under any EU law to
allow Chay Bowes to be added to the EU sanctions list. Because EU
sanctions renewals require unanimous agreement from all 27 Member
States, the Irish Government does not even need to block the wider
sanctions regime to act; it can simply inform Brussels that it will
withhold its consent at the six-month review unless the name of Chay
Bowes is removed from the list. Adding and renewing EU sanctions on an
Irish journalist who has not even been accused of committing any crime
amounts to Executive punishment without trial.
The basic rules of fairness between the European Union and national
courts are enshrined in two EU principles. The Principle of
Effectiveness means that national legal rules must never make it
virtually impossible or excessively difficult for a citizen to enforce
a right they have under EU law. The Principle of Equivalence means that
national courts must give citizens the same protections and remedies
for claims brought under EU laws as they would under Irish laws.
Normally, the Principles of Effectiveness and Equivalence stop
national governments from using local red tape to weaken EU rights. Conversely, the
Government should not use EU red tape to voluntarily weaken an Irish
citizen's constitutional rights when it is not obliged to do so under any
EU law either. A genuine attempt by an Irish court to find a way to rule on
this would demonstrate true sincere cooperation – ensuring that an
Executive merely mouthing EU talking points without sincerity to pursue
a particular political agenda cannot use the principle of Effectiveness
of European Law and the principle of Equivalence of Procedural Autonomy
as a smokescreen to undermine an Irish citizen's constitutional
protection under Bunreacht na hÉireann.
Increasingly, voluntarily signing up to EU measures behind closed doors
to bypass domestic democratic, constitutional, and environmental red
lines – allowing an inner circle within the Executive and state
agencies to override the public interest and erode Ireland's
deep-rooted traditions of neutrality and fair play – is becoming a
recurring Executive tactic in Ireland. In Gaelic Ireland, it was
famously said that unjust rulers feared the satire of the bards more
than the sword; today, the Executive uses EU sanctions to silence
inconvenient voices without a trial. How can we expect the Irish
Government to follow its own rules and fairly assess the public health,
climate, environmental and financial impacts of its attempts to import
US fracked gas into Ireland via LNG terminals on the Shannon Estuary
when its actions in targeting Irish journalists with EU sanctions are a
clear chilling warning to all dissenting political voices in a neutral
country?
ENDS
John McElligott - Tel.: 087-2804474 - Email: [email protected]